Home

By Robert A. Vella

This Sunday, the 49th edition of the National Football Leagues’s Super Bowl extravaganza will be played in Glendale, Arizona. It is expected to attract some 120 million viewers worldwide and generate at least $330 million in network ad revenue alone. Even though I’ve been a lifelong fan, I won’t be watching this year.

My one-man boycott is not likely to gain any support. The NFL is hugely popular. It’s so huge, in fact, that it has become a cultural institution which has transcended the normal realm of sports; and, this is precisely the reason for my boycott. Historian, politician, and writer Sir John Dalberg-Acton (a.k.a. Lord Acton) once wrote:

“Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely.”

Like many other social institutions in the 21st century – such as those in business, government, and religion – the NFL has gotten too big and is corrupting itself. One of the participant teams in this year’s contest, the New England Patriots, is embroiled in yet another high-profile scandal. The latest one is being called “Deflategate.” A previous scandal known as “Spygate” called into question the legitimacy of the franchise’s successful run since the early 2000s. Both involve allegations of, and documented proof of, cheating to gain competitive advantage.

The latest revelations have come at an inopportune time for the league, during the publicity-rich interlude between the AFC/NFC championship games and the Super Bowl, and after a season marred by domestic violence scandals involving Ray Rice, Adrian Peterson, as well as several other players. Furthermore, this season comes on the heels of other recent scandals such as “Bountygate” and attempts by the NFL to cover up the serious health consequences of high-speed impacts and concussions.

The NFL’s public relations problem has gotten so bad that its former commissioner Paul Tagliabue criticized the current commissioner Roger Goodell for prioritizing profits above all else (see: http://www.sportingnews.com/nfl/story/2015-01-27/paul-tagliabue-roger-goodell-for-nfl-controversies), the legendary former head coach of the Miami Dolphins Don Shula derided the current Patriots’ head coach Bill Belichick as “Beli-cheat” (see: http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/eye-on-football/24945025/don-shula-refers-to-bill-belichick-as-beli-cheat), and the Hall of Fame former Chicago Bears player and coach Mike Ditka said that football is now too dangerous and that he wouldn’t want his son to play it (see: http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/opinion/commentary/chi-mike-ditka-football-dangerous-son-20150121-story.html).

Coincidentally or not, the NFL’s (i.e. Goodell’s) statement that its Deflategate investigation won’t be concluded until some weeks after the Super Bowl seems to lend credibility to Mr. Tagliabue’s accusation of single-minded greed. The league has also stated that it is focusing on a single locker-room attendant or ball-boy as being responsible for deflating the balls used by Patriots star quarterback Tom Brady in violation of NFL rules. How convenient scapegoating a low-level employee would be for a multi-billion dollar business, for one of its top franchises having a questionable record of fair-play, and for the owner of that franchise (Robert Kraft) who enjoys a close personal relationship with the business’s highest officer (Goodell)?

This is what happens when institutions become too big. They corrupt themselves not because its leaders are bad people, but because there is simply too much money and livelihoods at stake. Greed becomes all-consuming, and the lust for power becomes insatiable.

So, I’m urging you to load up on beer and salty snacks. Sit back and spend this Sunday watching Beli-cheat’s Patriots battle it out with those arrogant and unsavory Seahawks from Seattle. It will be a titanic duel between proud warriors in a great stadium. At the end, you can callously gesture thumbs-up or thumbs-down to the loser just like the Romans did in their coliseums two millennia ago. Besides, who really cares about institutional corruption?

15 thoughts on “Institutional Corruption and My One-Man Boycott of the Super Bowl

  1. The NFL has become a religion, complete with all the misplaced deference, abuse scandals, and millions of dollars wasted on a product that truly does not $ to by enjoyed or utilized. The NFL lost me this year as well. I’m finished with it. Not that they or anyone else gives a shit, but I am done supporting it by consuming it as a product.

    Like

  2. I won’t be watching either, Robert – but I don’t believe I ever have. The backlash and nastiness I lived through when I was advocating against the use of Native Americans as mascots/logos for sports’ teams put competitive sports in a whole new light for me.

    Like

      • Thank you, Robert! I applaud your advocacy. It’s been awhile, but I do remember collecting information about issues around the country. At one point, I was preparing evidence and assembling a team of expert witnesses for a legal challenge to a local school district mascot/team name. Although the case never materialized, the information I collected was used by a team of lawyers in an earlier legal challenge to the logos used by the Washington and Cleveland teams…

        Liked by 1 person

  3. The relationship between large scale, leading to large wealth leading inevitably to corruption is a very relevant insight, especially with regard to ” too big to fail” banks. And the direction globalisation has taken us.

    Like

  4. Although I do hear, at the farthest edge of my hearing, that there is such a thing as a Super Bowl, I have never watched such silliness played out by supposed adults. So, Robert, I want to be included in your boycott. Professional football, indeed football generally, is the moral equivalent of Rome’s coliseum.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s